Confusion
abounds about vitamin supplements
for active people: Should you take
them? Which ones are best? When
should you take them? Will they
enhance sports performance? Here
is information to help clear up
any confusion and show you how to
meet your vitamin needs without
wasting money on unnecessary supplements.
What
Are Vitamins?
Vitamins are food substances
that assist essential biochemical
reactions within your body. There
are 13 known vitamins:
Four
fat-soluble vitamins-- A, D, E,
and K-- which your body stores in
amounts large enough to last for
months; and Nine water-soluble vitamins:
C (ascorbic acid), and the B-complex
vitamins--B1 (thiamin), B2 (riboflavin),
B6 (pyridoxine), B12, niacin, folic
acid, biotin, and pantothenic acid.
Your body is able to store enough
of these vitamins to last for several
weeks.
The Best Source: Food
Most people can get an adequate
supply of vitamins from a 1,200-
to 1,500-calorie-per-day diet consisting
of a variety of wholesome foods.
For athletes who get 2,500 to 4,000
or more calories a day, the task
is relatively simple. For example,
a thirsty teenage athlete who needs
over 4,000 calories per day can
easily get almost three times the
recommended 60 milligrams (mg) of
vitamin C from 16 ounces of orange
juice. And that's just from one
beverage there's even more in food.
The
trick to getting enough vitamins
is to choose foods that are nutritional
powerhouses. Fresh fruits and vegetables
are the ultimate natural vitamin
sources. Unlike supplements, fruits
and vegetables offer far more than
just the vitamins--they also contain
fiber and various other compounds
that are important to health. If
you eat a balanced diet you'll get
these important nutrients and you
won't need vitamin supplements to
correct nutritional deficiencies.
Unfortunately, most Americans eat
fewer than the recommended 5 servings
of fruits and vegetables per day.
Who
Needs Supplements?
To date, no evidence suggests
that extra vitamins will enhance
athletic performance, increase strength
or endurance, increase energy, or
build muscles. Certainly, a vitamin
deficiency can impair performance,
but deficiencies are generally related
to conditions such as anorexia,
unhealthy weight loss, malabsorption,
or poor eating habits. Deficiencies
are unlikely in active people with
robust appetites.
For
very active people, vitamin E is
a possible exception to the "eat
your vitamins" rule, because
even though a hungry athlete eats
a lot of food, diet is unlikely
to provide large enough amounts
of this nutrient. Vitamin E is an
antioxidant, which means it helps
fight damage to body cells. It may
help reduce the tissue damage associated
with intense exercise. Researchers
are still trying to determine if
extra vitamin E offers benefits
for athletes.
Although
outright vitamin deficiencies are
rare, some people are at risk for
marginal vitamin shortages. Supplements
can be appropriate for:
Dieters.
People who restrict their food intake
to less than 1,200 calories per
day may miss out on important nutrients.
This also includes people who eat
only a few types of foods or have
anorexia.
People who are lactose intolerant.
Active people who are unable to
digest the milk sugar found in dairy
foods commonly eliminate milk and
other dairy foods from their diets.
Lack of dairy foods can result in
a deficiency of riboflavin (as well
as calcium, a mineral).
People who have food allergies.
If you can't eat certain types of
foods, such as wheat or fruit, you
may have a harder time getting certain
nutrients.
Vegans. Active people who eat no
animal foods may become deficient
in vitamins B12, D, and riboflavin
(as well as the minerals iron and
zinc).
Women who might become pregnant
or are already pregnant. Before
becoming pregnant, women should
eat a diet that is rich in folic
acid. This means eating generous
amounts of spinach, broccoli, oranges,
and lentils, and also taking 400
micrograms of folic acid daily.
This vitamin, when taken at the
time of conception, helps to prevent
neurologic problems in the fetus,
and can reduce certain types of
birth defects.
Active people who are at risk for
heart disease and cancer. Although
the evidence is preliminary and
controversial, 100 to 400 international
units (IUs) of vitamin E is unlikely
to cause harm, and its antioxidant
properties may be beneficial (1).
Some people simply like to take
a multiple vitamin pill for health
insurance. This is practical as
long as the pill just supplements
healthy eating. People who take
handfuls of pills in hopes of finding
a cure-all are likely to feel better
if they improve their diet instead.
No amount of pills can compensate
for a deficient diet.
Choosing
Supplements
Prompted by persuasive advertising,
many active people have developed
a big appetite for vitamin pills.
Here are some tips to help you sort
through the hype and get the most
from a vitamin
supplement:
Choose
a multiple vitamin with approximately
100% of the daily values (or DV--formerly
known as the recommended dietary
allowance, or USRDA); this will
provide a safe and adequate balance
of vitamins. It is highly unlikely
that you need more. "High potency"
vitamins enhance manufacturers'
profits more than they enhance your
health.
Because a person is rarely deficient
in just one vitamin, a multiple
vitamin is preferable to large doses
of single vitamins (unless the vitamin
is prescribed by a physician for
a medical condition).
Claims about "natural"
vitamins in pills tend to be false,
given the prohibitive costs of extracting
vitamins from natural sources. In
reality, almost all vitamins in
supplements are synthetic. Besides,
naturally occurring and manufactured
vitamins have identical chemical
structures. The one exception is
vitamin E, which, in its natural
form, is slightly better absorbed
and used. But for long-term use--and
people generally take vitamin E
for chronic conditions--the price
of natural vitamin E may be too
high to justify the slight advantage.
Store brands are likely to be identical
to name brands, only much lower
in price. Ten dollars a month is
more than enough for vitamin supplements.
The label "stress tablets"
is a marketing ploy. There is little
evidence that the stresses of daily
living deplete the body of vitamins.
Evidence about the connection between
stress and vitamin depletion pertains
mostly to physical stress from surgery,
burns, or fever, not psychological
stress.
Supplements made without sugar or
starch offer no advantages.
Taking beta-carotene is better than
taking vitamin A, which is described
on labels as palmitate, acetate,
or fish oil. Beta-carotene, from
which the body makes vitamin A,
acts as an antioxidant and is safer
than vitamin A. If taken for several
months in doses greater than 25,000
IUs per day, vitamin A can be toxic.
Taking a supplement with or after
meals optimizes absorption. Vitamins
tend to work together with other
nutrients.
Many active people are already getting
abundant vitamins from fortified
foods such as breakfast cereals,
energy bars, sports drinks, and
snack foods. You don't even need
to take a vitamin pill if, for example,
you eat a big bowl of a cereal fortified
with 100% of the DVs for breakfast
or as a snack.
Invest
in Nutrition
If you don't know whether you're
getting adequate vitamins in your
food, consult with a registered
dietitian who specializes in nutrition.
He or she can evaluate your diet
and teach you how to optimize your
food intake.